Answers: Yes or No
Overall publication value of the article
Is the subject an important one?
Does the article possess scientific/practical/educational value?
Is the case clearly presented?
Does the case add any novel findings to current knowledge?
Original report / Review
Is the interpretation of the results clearly presented and adequately supported by the evidence ?
Are the references up-to-date?
Have the most important previous studies been cited?
Manuscript should be
Special Reviewer’s comments