| Questions | Answers: Yes or No |
Overall publication value of the article | Is the subject an important one? | |
Does the article possess scientific/practical/educational value? | |
Case Report | Is the case clearly presented? | |
Does the case add any novel findings to current knowledge? | |
Original report / Review | Is the interpretation of the results clearly presented and adequately supported by the evidence ? | |
References | Are the references up-to-date? | |
Have the most important previous studies been cited? | |
Reviewer’s recommendation | Manuscript should be published corrected rejected | |
|
|
Special Reviewer’s comments (optional) | |
Date | |